Back to:

 

Choosing the right tree

Getting to know your site

When forest managers refer to site characteristics, they are talking about a broad range of physical and chemical properties. Once you know a site's characteristics, you can determine what species will grow well (and those that won’t!). In most cases, there will be a few species that should do well on the site - think about the many different species you find in most natural forests. This gives you a chance to base your final species selection on additional considerations like long-term objectives, species availability and cost.

Although your site may have several unique characteristics that separate it from others, only two, soil type and drainage, influence how well one species will do compared to another.

Soil type

Although you don’t have to be a soils scientist to plant trees, knowing a little about soil is valuable. Trees depend on soil to anchor them in place, provide moistureand nutrients, and to act as a seedbed for future generations. All soils are made up of four main ingredients: mineral particles (the bulk of the material), air spaces between the particles, water in varying amounts, and some organic matter from plant and animal debris. Classifying soils is primarily a quantification of the different ingredients found within it.

Mineral particles range from boulders as large as basketballs, to tiny particles so small that can’t be seen without a powerful microscope. Soil texture is the relative proportion of the individual particles. A handful of dirt rubbed between your fingers will have a certain amount of ‘grittiness’ to it. The more abrasive the soil feels the larger the individual particles; the smoother the soil feels the smaller the particles. This grittiness (or the lack of it) is a relative measure of three main soil particle sizes – sand, silt and clay. Sand has the largest particles, which feel "gritty". Silt has medium sized particles that feel soft, silky or "floury”. Clay has the smallest particles and feels "sticky". The amount of sandversus silt versus clay within the soil directly affects a tree species' ability to grow on a site.

There are three broad textural classes: sandy soils, loamy soils and clay soils. The term loam refers to soils with more equal proportions of sand, silt and clay. Although there can be many combinations of classes such as sandy loam, loamy sand or even clay loam, it is only really necessary to determine which of the three general classes you have.

Table 1 lists some common properties to look for when assessing a soil texture class. Grab a handful of soil - does it feel gritty or smooth? Squeeze the soil in your hand. Does it form a cast (clump)? Lightly wet the soil and try it again. Try to make a soil ribbon (Fig. 1) by lightly wetting the soil until it feels like moist putty. Then, try to squeeze it between your thumb and forefinger upwardly into a thin flat ribbon – if a ribbon forms the soil contains clay. The longer the ribbon, the more clay it contains.


Fig. 1. Making a soil ribbon (source: http://ltpwww.gsfc.nasa.gov/
globe/stories/clays.htm)

Table 1. Soil texture class assessment properties
Soil Texture Class
Visual Appearance
Reaction when squeezed
in the hand
Ability to form a ribbon
Dry Soil
Moist Soil
Sand
soils
Granular with easily detectable particles Will not form a cast, or cast easily falls apart Forms a cast that crumbles easily Cannot form a ribbon
Loam
soils
Low to moderately granular

Can form clumps/ clods when dry
Forms a cast that can be handled relatively easily Forms a cast that can be easily handled Pure loam cannot form a ribbon

Loam with more silt and clay will form a fragile ribbon
Clay
soils
Fine texture with very few large particles

When dry, forms hard clumps
Forms a cast that can be handled freely Forms a cast that can be worked and is cohesive Forms a long, flexible ribbon

Drainage

Drainage is the second site characteristic that needs to be assessed before making a species selection. How well your site holds water can have a dramatic impact on the long-term survival of different species.

Drainage is influenced by soil texture. The smaller the particle size the more water the site holds – a clay soil can hold considerably more moisture than a sandy soil. Soil depth, recent precipitation, topography, depth to the water table, and the amount and type of vegetation also influence drainage in one way or another.

Soil drainage can be classified into four different categories.

Well Drained – water drains from the site rapidly; water seldom pools on the site even during a heavy rain or after snow melt

Moderately Drained – water may pool but only for brief periods

Imperfectly Drained – water pools on the site, sometimes for extended periods especially during the spring or in wet years;

Poorly Drained – water drains slowly from the site throughout the year; soil
may appear wet below the surface.


Determining the drainage of your site is relatively easy and usually comes from observing what happens to the site in the spring and fall, as well as during and after a rainfall.

Site variability

The area you intend to plant may not be uniform especially if there is variation in topography. You should assess the entire site looking for differences that might affect your choice of species. If your site differs in either soil texture or drainage you may need to choose different species for certain areas.